View Point head image

A blog with a wide range of views about technology and its role in transforming communities,
economies, business and human behaviour.

17 Dec 2009
By Hugh Bradlow
Dec
17

Hugh Bradlow’s Kindle review

blog_kindle

I recently made the bold statement that I expect to see a billion eBook readers by the end of the next decade. This was based on no science whatsoever – it was simply an enthusiastic response to my receiving my first eBook reader in October this year when Amazon finally released an international version of their Kindle. Subsequent experience and the reaction of the many people who have got one has borne out my enthusiasm. This is going to be a massive disruption not only for the book publishers but also organisations such as libraries.

Ok, first of all I love the device (and this has nothing to do with my role as CTO or whatever plans we may or may not have here at Telstra).  I have one, I bought my daughter one for her birthday and I got one my wife one for Christmas (don’t tell her – she does not know it yet!).

Why do I like it?

  1. Convenience: you can read it with one hand (you don’t have to hold the pages of the book open). You can read it anywhere you can read a book (because the screen is just like a book). In fact the screen is so realistic I sometimes find myself trying to turn imaginary pages.
  2. Battery life: The secret of the Kindle (and any eBook reader) is the screen. If they use electronic ink, they don’t draw power unless you turn the page. You get about 2 weeks of battery life out of the thing.
  3. Compact: 1500 books on one thin device.
  4. Instant gratification: buy directly using the cellular network in a minute.
  5. Amazon backend: books, billing, service.
  6. Flexibility: Change the font size, or even have it do a very reasonable text to speech conversion if you want to listen to the book in the car or just because your eyes are tired. It turns the pages as it reads so you can pick up reading where you left off!
  7. Documents: You can put PDF’s and Word documents on it (via an email address).

What are the downsides?

  1. There will be a flood of eBooks on the market next year (e.g. Barnes & Noble are about to release one called the “Nook”, Sony and iRex already have them). They may be cheaper/better, etc – it is hard to tell. There are, however, 2 things to remember: (a) the screens are expensive so I don’t know how much downside there is in the price; (b) the Amazon set up is analogous to the iPhone integration with the Application Store, the end to end Amazon ecosystem is really good. Many articles are now appearing comparing eBook readers. See for example recent articles in the New York Times.
  2. Amazon control: you cannot load ePub (the open standard) books onto the device. You can however have Amazon convert any Doc, PDF into a Kindle format.
  3. Wireless charges: Because you are effectively roaming on an AT&T SIM card, you pay US$2 extra to download a book via the wireless network. You can however sideload for free via the Internet.
  4. Geographic constraints: There are 350,000 books available for the Kindle in the US, but only 250,000 in Australia.
  5. Lack of WiFi: Why is this a problem when you have a 3G service (and Australia has an incomparable one in the Next GTM network – by the way, the Kindle works better on Next GTM because it supports 3G at 850MHz but not 900MHz)? The answer lies in the way that libraries are likely to loan out eBooks – you will need to be in the library and connected to their WiFi network to borrow a book. This is still early days so this may change.

By Hugh Bradlow

Posts: 4

9 Comments

  1. Michael Lewis says:

    Hugh, I knew reading your blog would get me into some serious hi-tech trouble at home. The notion of owning an eBook has been bubbling away on my wish list for some time now. Having experienced the Kindle in some form on the iPhone (Amazon application – free download from AppStore), I want more! Hopefully I will have some interesting feedback from CES where eBooks are destined to shine.

  2. Dave Trotman says:

    Answer to Library problem – Bigpond Library

  3. Craig Brown says:

    My only concern with devices like Kindle is the cost and durability. if your reading a paper book on the train there is little fear of someone grabbing it and running; if you treat books like I do, they are thrown in the bottom of my bag and treated as a throw away item once read. Electronic devices mean that people need to outlay a substantial more money to get started, take care not to mistreat the device or drop it in the push of the crowded public transport, and so on.

    What are your views on the physical and financial aspects to people adopting devices like Kindle?

  4. Warren Jackson says:

    Hi Hugh, As an avid reader since early childhood I have been reluctant to move away from the tactile comfort of hard/paperback. But having collected so many books now and under pressure to declutter the bookcases, reading your article was the catalyst for moving to the 21st century. I just added a kindle to my wish list for christmas. Will add some more excitement for my technology advanced children when they shop this year. I hope you also have a safe and enjoyable christmas break with your family.

  5. sorita yong says:

    I am a huge fan of ebooks and have been using my ebook reader for over 6 years in the windows format, using Mobipocket and now E-Pub. I am not a huge fan of the kindle as I like my reader to be backlit so that i can read in bed at night without disturbing anyone or in the day when waiting at appointments. However the kindle has a place as backlit readers are not as easy to read in the daytime.
    I have a library of over 2000 books on me at any time and virtually stopped buying paper books since I got my ereader.
    Project Guttenberg offers readers many free classic ebooks for download and Fictionwise has weekly specials where you can download ebooks for free too.
    They are so easy to use and to download books to.

  6. Ivan Brekalo says:

    Devices like the Kindle face the same issues as devices like PDAs – there is so much crossover with devices such as smartphones that it hardly makes it worth it forking out hundreds of dollars for another device that you have to carry around. Download ‘Stanza’ (free) on your Iphone and you can download books wirelessly or through your PC. And since most people carry their phone all the time you permanently have a library of books to read at your fingertips!

  7. Kev says:

    The article mentioned that there are 100,000 fewer titles available in Australia due to “geographic constraints”. Upon comparing the Australian Kindle store to the US store, it appears that we are missing most of the current bestselling authors, including Dan Brown, Stephen King, etc. If you love Jane Austen, Jules Verne or Charles Dickens you’ll have no problem but if you were thinking of buying a kindle to read all the latest best sellers, you could be in for a rude surprise.

  8. Dan says:

    Great review Hugh especially that you covered the pro’s and cons so to speak.

    How do you think Apps like Kobo will compete on multi purpose devices like the iPhone compared with dedicated eBook readers? Kobo have signed up with Borders and is locally available on whatever device you use in Australia which seems more versatile.

    Do you think the Apple tablet rumours have any susbstance also – as that would be a real competitor if and when it comes to fruition. Personally I’m not quite ready to dish out the cash just yet for a Kindle, I still like the tactile experience (and oddly enough the smell of printed paper!) too much.

  9. Maurice says:

    Recent BBC radio show 29/12:
    http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b00pfl94/Front_Row_29_12_2009/

    The best paperless technology I have seen is Microsoft OneNote – annotation, hand-writing, OCR, translation, knowledge management, web-page capture, knowledge search. I’m waiting for 15″ tablet pc’s to arrive. Multi-display, large screen pc’s will become more common – one display in portrait orientation for page reading and one is landscape for image display.

    The 3D wirelass shutter glasses for gaming that have been around for a year or so are another interesting concept. One day, high-res glasses could replace screens.

Leave a Reply